Content Feed Comments Feed

Phinally Philly

Sports analysis and newspheed.

Why the Eagles Made a Mistake in Signing Mike Vick

Posted by David Foley On August - 13 - 2009

The Eagles signed Mike Vick to a two-year deal according to ESPN. Absolutely stunning; I’m in disbelief really.

Terms of the deal haven’t been announced but you’d have to assume they will be shortly.
I hate this move…absolutely hate it. I laughed when I first heard the rumors he may be coming here, but now that it is true I am in shock.
First things first, you need to think about what a huge distraction this is going to be for the team. Camp may be over, but you can assume every player on the roster will be asked how they feel about this at some point. It’d be like if the Phillies traded for Milton Bradley at the deadline: it’s an unnecessary risk by a team that was already set to be a playoff contender.
Does this really make the Eagles better? How will Vick be used? We don’t need another QB (unless Kevin Kolb’s injury is worse than reported.) You want to put him at receiver? He’s just going to steal reps from Desean Jackson and Jeremy Maclin. We all saw how well the Eagles ran the Wildcat last year, and it wasn’t pretty.
Then there are the questions surrounding his playing ability, which is a complete question mark. How his body will respond after being in prison for a couple years is entirely unpredictable. He wasn’t even a good passing quarterback before the dog fighting charges came to light, with a career 75.7 QB rating. I just fail to see how he fits on this roster, and if you are signing him just to be a backup then it isn’t worth the controversy and the increased media attention.
This is all without getting into what he did to end up in prison in the first place. Any human being who can torture an innocent animal has issues, and I see nothing in Vick’s demeanor that tells me he’s changed at all. Since the American public has the memory of a two year old, here’s a recap of what Vick did to his dogs…
“John Goodwin of the Humane Society said the manner in which losing or unwilling dogs were killed was especially troubling.
‘Some of the grisly details in these filings shocked even me, and I’m a person who faces this stuff every day,’ he said. ‘I was surprised to see that they were killing dogs by hanging them and one dog was killed by slamming it to the ground. Those are extremely violent methods of execution — they’re unnecessary and just sick.’
…In March 2003, after a pit bull from Bad Newz Kennels lost in a fight, it said Peace consulted with Vick about the losing dog’s condition, then executed it by wetting it with water and electrocuting it.
I’ll refrain from posting the pictures here; they’re just too disturbing.
You can say whatever you want about how he did his time and deserves a second chance: that’s fine, but it shouldn’t have been in Philadelphia. He doesn’t fill a need on offense, and he will be a massive distraction for a team that was already well-stocked with playmakers on that side of the ball. We don’t need his lacking abilities, his attitude, or his baggage.
I hate this move: it makes me sick to my stomach. The Eagles just got worse not only on the field, but off it as well.

Terms of the deal haven’t been announced but you’d have to assume they will be shortly.

I hate this move…absolutely hate it. I laughed when I first heard the rumors he may be coming here, but now that it is true I am in shock.

First things first, you need to think about what a huge distraction this is going to be for the team. Camp may be over, but you can assume every player on the roster will be asked how they feel about this at some point. It’d be like if the Phillies traded for Milton Bradley at the deadline: it’s an unnecessary risk by a team that was already set to be a playoff contender.

Ladies and gentlemen, the Eagles just got worse.

The Eagles just got worse in more ways than one.

Does this really make the Eagles better? How will Vick be used? We don’t need another QB (unless Kevin Kolb’s injury is worse than reported.) You want to put him at receiver? He’s just going to steal reps from Desean Jackson and Jeremy Maclin. We all saw how well the Eagles ran the Wildcat last year, and it wasn’t pretty.

Then there are the questions surrounding his playing ability, which is a complete question mark. How his body will respond after being in prison for a couple years is entirely unpredictable. He wasn’t even a good passing quarterback before the dog fighting charges came to light, with a career 75.7 QB rating. I just fail to see how he fits on this roster, and if you are signing him just to be a backup then it isn’t worth the controversy and the increased media attention.

This is all without getting into what he did to end up in prison in the first place. Any human being who can torture an innocent animal has issues, and I see nothing in Vick’s demeanor that tells me he’s changed at all. Since the American public has the memory of a two year old, here’s a recap of what Vick did to his dogs…

“John Goodwin of the Humane Society said the manner in which losing or unwilling dogs were killed was especially troubling.

‘Some of the grisly details in these filings shocked even me, and I’m a person who faces this stuff every day,’ he said. ‘I was surprised to see that they were killing dogs by hanging them and one dog was killed by slamming it to the ground. Those are extremely violent methods of execution — they’re unnecessary and just sick.’

…In March 2003, after a pit bull from Bad Newz Kennels lost in a fight, it said Peace consulted with Vick about the losing dog’s condition, then executed it by wetting it with water and electrocuting it.”

I’ll refrain from posting the pictures here; they’re just too disturbing.

You can say whatever you want about how he did his time and deserves a second chance: that’s fine, but it shouldn’t have been in Philadelphia. He doesn’t fill a need on offense, and he will be a massive distraction for a team that was already well-stocked with playmakers on that side of the ball. We don’t need his lacking abilities, his attitude, or his baggage.

I hate this move: it makes me sick to my stomach. The Eagles just got worse not only on the field, but off it as well.

You might like these related articles:

  • http://www.professionalrecipes.com/ Jeff

    If this is true, I just lost respect for the Eagles, their coach and their owner and I will no longer be an Eagles fan.

  • Moonbr01

    You're soft and don't deserve to wear eagle green, why don't you write about Donte Stallworth who killed a person but only served 30 days in jail and got suspended for a year from the NFL

  • http://twitter.com/JGiansante Joseph Giansante

    He served his time, he paid the price. He got his 2nd chance. The Eagles have a strong infrastructure, a solid locker room, Vick has come out and announced that he knows his place and will not try to “challenge” McNabb for his spot, I almost guarantee it. Plus he can't even play until…what? week 7? It's going to be an experiment, and I think that if we can just forgive and forget and move the hell on that with Kolb going down Vick would be a solid option.

    AND we're a team that is now built around blistering speed and Vick sure as shit has that. I'm one of those guys that is over steroids, I'm over Vick's dog thing, I'm over it all. He did his time and now it's time to move on. The media will be a bit of a distraction maybe, but we should still be able to move past it and take our team to the post season. Until proven otherwise I will remain optimistic, even supportive.

  • http://twitter.com/JGiansante Joseph Giansante

    Amen.

  • http://twitter.com/phillyfoley David Foley

    @Moonbr01
    I did write about that. Last time I checked the Eagles didn't sign Stallworth today.

    @Joseph
    How do you know Vick still has speed? It was the only redeeming thing about him as a football player but that was when he was in his prime. Now he's fast approaching 30…I'd be stunned if he's half the threat he used to be running. As for passing…let's just not go there.

  • as3000

    As a Falcons fan, I can't even begin to tell you how bad he was his last 2 seasons were here in Atlanta. He had 2 all pro caliber receivers in Crumpler & White & could never get them the ball. I think the Eagles coaching staff thinks he can still run like he did against the Vikings & he hasn't run like that in years. AND then there's the premeditated violence against dogs. Folks who do that have either experienced traumatic violence as a child or is prone to it in the future. He needs therapy, not Tony Dungy, and certainly not football.

  • http://twitter.com/phillyfoley David Foley

    I failed to mention his prior incidents, including the Ron Mexico debacle, and the middle finger he gave to falcons fans after a game.
    Vick is a headcase. If I ran a team that was in the cellar I might bring him on for the fans he'd inevitably bring in, but the Eagles don't need him.

  • as3000

    It's not his 2nd chance. Ron Mexico, getting busted with drugs at the airport in Miami, killing dogs and failing a drug test the day before his trial.

  • http://twitter.com/akeirans akeirans

    I don't remember seeing anyone make such a big deal when Brett Myers punched his wife in the face a few years back. He wins you a World Series and it's all good. Donte Stallworth kills someone and serves less than a month in jail. How about Ray Lewis? How about good old Brandon Marshall? Vick served his time. I don't know if he has the skills or how the team will use him, but that's not my job.

  • as3000

    Actually it's Vick who's soft. He didn't like it when ATL reporters questioned his work ethic or play. He threw fits like a lil' girl. You think he's going to be able to stand up to the scrutiny he's about to go through this year. I just don't think the Eagles did their homework.

  • as3000

    I think that what's getting folks upset is that it wasn't an isolated incident like Myers or Stallworth but premeditated violence over the course of several years. If he hadn't been caught Vick would still be running Bad Newz Kennels. Violence is violence and it's been going on unchecked for years. Don't forget his battery case as Ron Mexico. Yeah he served his time but did he ever get counseling?

  • as3000

    It's not his 2nd chance. People keep writing that and it couldn't be further from the truth.

  • http://twitter.com/akeirans akeirans

    IMO a human life is worth much more than any animal's life. I think abuse towards women is a lot worse than anything regarding dogs/animals. When they are in prison they go to counseling they speak with people and are involved with programs. I am not signing off on VIck as man of the year, but think that people act really high and mighty like they don't make mistakes. Two years of his life behind bars is a lot of time.

  • Ben (@iBenjammin)

    He fought dogs before, was arrested and kept doing it? Or are you talking about giving the fans the finger…come on.

    Dude has issues and the Birds are reaching out to him. You think it's better he stays away from the only thing he knows how to do? The Eagles did their homework and talked to animal rights groups, and even Mayor Nutter. I trust Eagles management.

  • billgraffssweatervest

    Massive distraction???? Whatta you talking about? How many locker rooms have you been in? Well-stocked playmakers on offense? Our top 3 receivers are all slot receivers. One's a 2nd yr player (Jackson); One's a rook (Maclin) & One has 1 hamstring (Curtis). The next best receiver is Hank Baskett who has wapping 71 career receptions. Oh yeah, we have a running back that has only practiced 3 times in as many years. I love em too, but I'm not as convinced as you are that they can't use a talent like Vick. If his skills are lacking as you say and his attitude and baggage is in question, why would up to 11 (according to espn) other teams have shown interest in him? You must have dogs. Gotta get over that Foley, it's not about that. Ray Lewis watched his friend kill somebody and refused to participate with authorities, but he's a role model today, AAANNNND he has a ring. Who cares. BUT it should be interesting to see how Eagle tailgaters interact with the tree-huggin PETA nuts.

  • http://twitter.com/akeirans akeirans

    I agree bill esp. re: Ray Lewis. Look at Stallworth he did less than a month for murder. I'd love to know what it is like for so many people to be so perfect.

  • Ben (@iBenjammin)

    Amen sir.

  • Ben (@iBenjammin)

    You think you know more than Eagles management? Come on man…

  • Ben (@iBenjammin)

    Whoa whoa whoa!

    First, I am a dog lover and dog owner and think what Vick did was despicable.

    That said everyone deserves a second chance and a rehabilitated Vick who can return to society and to football in a positive way will do more for protecting dogs and animals in the future than exiling him from football and the public.

    I trust Eagles management and find it puzzling to criticize them before you have heard anything from the team or have seen how the are going to use him on the field. You know he won’t be playing QB (I have to think McNabb ok’ed this signing), and he won’t even be on the field until presumably 6 weeks or so into the season.

    Appreciate your passion, but let’s see what happens before we jump all over this move. Everyone deserves a second chance.

    -Ben

  • vandal

    I for one am all for this signing, its freaking football people. The professional athlete as a role model arguement is stupid, its another excuse for parents to avoid explaining anything uncomfortable to their children. thats being said what he did was wrong, yes, but everyone makes mistakes, some of them are larger than others. But what we all deserve is another chance to prove that we were acting stupid and that we can change. the eagles are a classy organization and a great group of guys for vick to surround himself with. the fanbase is strong and unforgiving so hopefully he will feel the pressure to act accordingly. let the guy have another chance and let him live his life.

  • hawaiian1

    I am very disappointed in the NFL for not making players adhere to the NFL's Code of Conduct. Be it Pacman Jones, Michael Vick or players who were arrested for disorderly conduct, carrying a concealed weapon, drug charges, or being involved in criminal activities. When will the NFL say – hey, you get one chance – you screw it up, you're out. There are plenty of talented players who would appreciate the opportunity of playing in the NFL who will watch their P's and Q's if they know what's at risk if they screw up.

  • hawaiian1

    I am very disappointed in the NFL for not making players adhere to the NFL's Code of Conduct. Be it Pacman Jones, Michael Vick or players who were arrested for disorderly conduct, carrying a concealed weapon, drug charges, or being involved in criminal activities. When will the NFL say – hey, you get one chance – you screw it up, you're out. There are plenty of talented players who would appreciate the opportunity of playing in the NFL who will watch their P's and Q's if they know what's at risk if they screw up.

blog comments powered by Disqus

About Us

Phinally Philly is a new source for news in the world of Philadelphia sports. Unlike other forms of mainstream media we take pride in presenting our honest, uncensored take on anything and everything related to Philly sports. We’re breaking news, insightful commentary, and a whole lot more brought to you live from the City of Brotherly Love by the Philly fan, for the Philly fan.