For the second consecutive season, the biggest news in Spring Training will come down to who the 5th spot in the rotation will belong to when the Phillies head north.
Last season, the race was between Kyle Kendrick, J.A. Happ, and Chan Ho Park. With Chopper moving on to the Yankees and Happ solidifying his spot in the middle of the rotation, there was bound to be a new competition for the last spot in the rotation.
The race is primarily between Kendrick and Jamie Moyer, with a few other long shots in case neither of those two perform.
Kendrick made his spring debut against the Yankees yesterday, following in the footsteps of his new role model, Roy Halladay. Kendrick has been working out with Roy and has even started to sport the same facial hair style. If he pitches like Halladay, the Phillies will be in good shape. In his two innings of work, Kendrick gave up one hit to go along with one strikeout. Not a bad debut.
Jamie Moyer made his spring training debut this morning in a B game, going three innings. He gave up three singles, no runs or walks and three strikeouts. He threw 31 pitches and got 23 of them over for strikes. An impressive start for the old goat. I’m actually surprised to see Moyer throwing off of a mound at all this early in camp. After his offseason surgeries, I thought he wouldn’t be ready until closer to the season opener. At this stage in his career, Moyer knows what he needs to do in order to be prepared for the season, so he should be alright. Granted, he knows this is a competition and will do everything he can to show he can still ptich.
Obviously, the Phillies want the Kendrick of a few years ago when he came up from Reading and won 10 games his first year and 11 the next. After losing out last year and starting out in Lehigh Valley, Kendrick came back late in the season and won a few games for the Phils down the stretch. If he can develop his other pitches, he’ll be a sold pitcher for the big club.
Moyer had an up and down season last year. While still winning 12 games, he was bumped out of the rotation to make room for Pedro Martinez and sent to the bullpen. Jamie pitched extremely well out of the bullpen and made a few spot starts until getting injured late in the season. After a few complications from surgery, Moyer seems to be back on track to be ready for Opening Day in a month.
It’s hard to tell what the Phillies would prefer out of this race. While they have a lot of money committed to Moyer, the team has been known to eat money when it comes to under performing players. (Adam Eaton, anyone?) Plus, the Phillies want to see if Kendrick can come back to the major leagues and pitch at a high level. If he can, he’ll be a valuable part of the rotation for the next few years.
At the end of spring training, if Moyer and Kendrick have pitched pretty similar, I see the 5th spot going to Moyer. Keep Kendrick around in the ‘pen for long relief and spot starts. His confidence would get shattered beyond repair if he has to start in Lehigh again. Keep him around with the big club in case Moyer falters. Jamie probably knows that this should be his final season, so he’ll be going all out to make it successful.
By the end of the season, I think Moyer will have made more starts than Kendrick, but it will be close.



